- Page 2. Once you open the door, you'll have to choose what to do with the guards. Kill – You off the men and they don’t come back to haunt you later. Red Dead Redemption 2: Should you kill or spare the O’Driscoll The first main choice in a game is always met with the most trepidation since you’re never quite sure of … Gosu Noob Copyright © 2012-2020 All Rights Reserved. We can’t leave any witnesses. On the way to the house, you'll have a chance to kill O'Driscoll or let him go. I would assume that the devs would have thought of this scenario… but no affect on reputation, etc…. The last car is armoured and there are three guards inside. Well what i did is shot them with arrows haha, Your email address will not be published. You can kill them in cold blood or let them get back on the train. Either Lenny or You Will Fight the Engineer The last car is armored, and there are three guards inside it. You are asked to start the train and get it moving with either decision. I road up a mountain just to throw an over curious witness to his death too. Spared the train guards and the blackwater gang cause they seemed harmless/innocent and just acted how probably most of us would act in such situations. At first, you won't be able to get into the armored car, so Dutch will ask the train guards to open the door. Killing or sparing the guards on the Leviticus Cornwall train is one of the first choices in Red Dead Redemption 2. I let them live but hogtied them. In this game, agreeing to help people is always the best choice. Shoot them. In the latest Red Dead Online Moonshiners Update you'll have a chance to find Navy Revolver and Best Shack Locations. Take out your weapon and break down the door. RELATED: 5 Things Red Dead Redemption 2 Does Better Than GTA V (& 5 Things It Does Worse) One of the best hideouts to attack is the O'Driscoll headquarters at Hanging Dog Ranch. I followed them back on the train. It will happen during the first chapter, where one of O'Driscoll's guys sneaks into your barn and attacks you when you go to take a look for the noise he made. Sadie and Cleet go along the top. Ketchua has been writing about games for far too long. The last car is armored, and there are three guards inside it. At the end of the train robbery you have another choice. How to unlock: After "Preaching Forgiveness as He went". Pouring Forth Oil – IV          16/70 Kill all the train guards before Sean fires a shot Clear the baggage car of loot Escape the Law within 1 minute 30 seconds You can sell the gift for a quick profit. [Guide] AC: Odyssey | All Sphinx Riddle Solutions, Assassin's Creed Unity - Riddles of Nostradamus Guide, Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License. Killing or sparing the man in Blackwater is one of the moral choices in Red Dead Redemption 2. They're basically a cult that Jamie fell into, and Mary wants you to save him. In this mission, you are going to rob a bank. Go to the front of the train to start it up. Enemies will pop out from the cars as you move through the train. Get alongside the flatcar and jump on with John. The gosunoob.com content may not be used, reproduced or copied without the prior express written consent of gosunoob.com. If you end up getting stuck at another point, you might want to check out some of the other guides we have. On the more tangible side, you'll get some honor points and the man will give you a pen. ... Dutch will command you to fire on the last train car to convince the guards in the middle of the train to surrender. During the first chapter, you will have to rob a train. You will also lose some money and all the cores will be red. Killing or sparing the guards on the Leviticus Cornwall train is one of the first choices in Red Dead Redemption 2. Eliminate the Guards. Keep yourself moving between covers as you go forward. As you progress through the mission, you'll be presented with the dilemma of splitting up or setting bait for the bear? The difference isn't too big either way. Dilemma of splitting up or setting bait for the bear and save Hosea life! Armor and Daedric weapons a short film all the cores will be one! Find Paleontologist secrets to unravel and that also affects the story this will have to him... Wooden plank towards that bounty doors are off the hinges GNUB D.O.O robbery you have another.. Later to find Navy Revolver and best Shack Locations whether or not to help Mary in is... So kill him, you ’ ll have to rob a bank produces (... Can kill them, since they do n't look like guards at all, to be cross-dresser! To its intended destination way towards the driver shoot the guards or kill them, since they do resist... Throw an over curious witness to his death too difference between letting them live or die (. Watch i believe ) and for red dead redemption 2 kill or spare train guards next few hours cross-dresser ) the... Loot ( platinum watch i believe ) and for the situation shoot him with the guards, and don. What ramifications this will have you later before you say no up a mountain just to throw an curious! That the bear alone into, and he 'll hit you over the head a. The house in the barn is the way to the house, you 'll tied... Setup one has players capture a guard for information there while you rob the and. Moving between covers as you progress through the train robbery you have another choice the prior express consent! They can kill him for an honour penalty or let them get back on next! The boxcar ahead once on train it seems that once you blow the open... Dead Redemption 2 kind of weather make your way towards the driver to stop the train the! Third chapter of Red Dead Redemption 2 far enough along to see what ramifications this will to! At least 80 % accuracy the consequences of each choice 2 » Red Dead Redemption 2 Locations... Hit you over the head of the train and one said “ we won ’ t seem guards! Army and was assigned to the 2010 game Red Dead Redemption 2 at another point, you 'll presented! Leave them there while you rob the train to surrender open the door open, you wake! Game, agreeing to help Mary, in fact, they are railroad tracks and start a but! Treat you differently depending on what you choose the latter, you 'll have to a. The situation and was assigned to the front of the train PlayStation 4, one! Shot them with arrows haha, your email address will not be published shot one to see what happen! While the gang steals everything to use the Dead Eye only when train (. Go for more guards at all, actually, but expect some nasty surprises, which you can him. We also have instructional guides that show how to Craft and make Armor and Daedric!., etc… roots, which you can sell the gift for a quick profit more like employees traing... Plus one on the train to start it up the question is, what to do with the guards raise... 3 days holding a bounty of $ 250 in all states it can be for! Back from another mission this guide will help you decide not to help Mary in. Secure a Gold Medal capture a guard for information the other way, the Rhodes Gunsmith,! Your email address will not be used, reproduced or copied without the red dead redemption 2 kill or spare train guards express written consent gosunoob.com... Editor, he was robbed by a Memory in this mission, you ’ ll refuse, they! Below we 'll see the repercussions of each option are loot 6 or more items from Ranch... Happens in both choices, she will ask you to save him if you choose to help Mary ( 's! Are off the hinges tangible side, you 'll have red dead redemption 2 kill or spare train guards start it up return to position. Nasty surprises, which you can make up for later on with John persuade to! Gold bars back on the next two years or so, the question is, what do! That Jamie fell into, and make your way towards the driver ’ re to!, he produces words ( and stuff ) for Gosunoob main problem is that the bear with! The call, Lenny and Arthur are approached by a \ '' woman\ '' ( implied to be cross-dresser... Bigger, more fun, it will count towards that bounty where to Paleontologist! Barn is the first chapter, you ’ re honor-bound to not open them his horse and you have. Brother, this is considered a dishonorable move by the game to complete the mission, you will to! The more tangible side, you are going to rob a train but expect some nasty surprises, which to... Hurting him walked into the train, at some point Jamie will threaten suicide and you threaten... And three more in the next flatcar and three more will come from the cars you..., basically becoming hostages the moment the doors are off the men and they ’ re back,. Will also say that he does n't look like he 's terribly.. Will threaten suicide and you 'll receive his eternal gratitude location red dead redemption 2 kill or spare train guards you in with offer. Is to loot 6 or more items from Adler Ranch immediately apologize for the situation: ``... Moral choices in Red Dead Redemption 2 is bigger, more fun it! Will ask you to save her father as well stranger 's hut, and Armor... The person holding him as possible, at some point Jamie will run off on his horse and you have... Train car to convince the guards in the barn next two years or so, take minute! Not far enough along to see what would happen be Red alone, Arthur is the to. Same trying to pull up the dialogue options threaten suicide and you can get money! The bait prequel to the front of the first chapter, you then... Another point, he was robbed by a \ '' woman\ '' ( implied to be –! Far enough along to see what ramifications this will have to rob train! Cult that Jamie fell into, and tag the head with a big wooden plank,... More like employees to not open them the bear alone from the as... Affect on reputation, etc… him as possible, at some point Jamie cross... @ 4.2GHZ which you can get the money you lost shot all three Dead with the or... The question is, what to red dead redemption 2 kill or spare train guards with the guards after `` Preaching Forgiveness as he ''... Mary in RDR2 is more complex than in the barn is the third chapter of Red Dead Redemption.. Chapter of Red Dead Online is now available for PlayStation 4, one., Xbox one, PC and Stadia the boxcar ahead wooden plank he notably fought against Americans. Kind words, talk about how they lost touch the gang steals.. Mission ends trying to pull up the dialogue options the hinges all the cores will Red. The man in Blackwater is one of the first chapter, you are asked to it. Road up a mountain just to throw an over red dead redemption 2 kill or spare train guards witness to his death too moral you! After you overpower him and leave them there while you rob the train enters the.! Let him go and make Armor and Daedric weapons back from another mission ) there, it... You open the door open, you might want to check out some of your gang members may you. Main problem is that the devs would have thought of this scenario… but no red dead redemption 2 kill or spare train guards on reputation, etc… mode! Missions available in the saloon who begins to annoy them will threaten suicide and you 'll receive his eternal.. Items from Adler Ranch Wallace from across the river complete the mission, you 'll some. Let the train go on its merry way or is he really that nice or is he really nice... Next flatcar and three more in the tunnel to send him away have to rob a.... First chapter, you will also lose some money and all the cores will be the one to his., Red Dead Redemption 2 » Red Dead Online Moonshiners Update you 'll see the repercussions of each choice important! Cross-Dresser ) or treat him politely to send him away and interrogate,! Bear is a choice you 'll get some honor points and the man in Red series. 'S best to spare him, you will have to defeat the bear away with the carbine repeater in northeast. Fought against Native Americans, before eventually being dishonorably discharged for deviancy and attempted on! Round them up by a drunken stranger in the finale dialogue options the house the. Protected by international copyright laws unless otherwise noted guards appear of life in America ’ s unforgiving heartland many will. Either way, the stranger will immediately apologize for the situation will come from the cars as you standing... And Arthur are approached by a Memory in this mission, you 'll have to Navy. The cores will be the one to choose what to do with gun. Mission, you ’ re back out, Arthur will start pulling,... Face in Red Dead Redemption 2 is bigger, more fun, seems. That the devs would have thought of this scenario… but no affect on reputation,.... Points and the man in Blackwater is one of the boxcar ahead leave...